Geeky Nigeria
Education

Universities are warehouses for intelligence machines

Mmesoma Okwuoma21 min read

Edited by Paul Elegbeleye and Aloho Esiekpe

Universities are warehouses for intelligence machines

Prof. Yakubu Aboki Ochefu, an Economic History scholar of considerable standing and the former Secretary General of the Committee of Vice-Chancellors of Nigerian Universities, has argued that the country's universities have fallen short because they settled for storing knowledge when what the nation needed were machines that generate intelligence.

The professor made the remarks on Thursday while serving as the 10th Convocation Lecturer of Federal University Lokoja, addressing 5,638 graduates, 192 of whom earned doctorates. His lecture was titled “The Confluence Generation: The University, The Graduate, and The Society That Must Become Our Laboratory.”

Key point: Our institutions are Mode 1 seats of learning placed in a nation brimming with Mode 2 difficulties.

He opened with the meeting point of two rivers at Lokoja, where the River Niger, flowing from the Guinea highlands, joins the River Benue, which comes from the Cameroon highlands, at Mount Patti. In clear weather, the two waters can be seen in their separate colours flowing together along one channel without blending, and they only combine further downstream.

Two rivers that never mix

In his view, the Nigerian higher-education sector and wider society have behaved like two rivers sharing a single channel without ever mixing. Campus life, he said, keeps time with academic calendars, the Senate and scholarly journals, while everyday existence beyond the gates is about floods, markets, clogged roads and hunger. Students about to graduate, he added, stand at the point where the two currents are bound at last to meet.

How Nigerian universities came to be

Looking back over the record, he noted that Lokoja became the seat of government for Northern Nigeria on 1 January 1900. Colonial rulers set up schools meant to produce clerks, translators and medical assistants, and later established Yaba Higher College in the 1930s and University College Ibadan in 1948. When the country gained self-rule, its universities existed to supply the state with personnel, and the bargain was plain: earn a degree, then step into a government post.

Around the middle of the 1980s, income from oil had fallen, Structural Adjustment had arrived, and the government had frozen recruitment. The government never again became the employer it once was, yet the factory carried on turning out the same product.

The lone university college of 1948 has multiplied into 328 institutions of higher learning at present, every one taking in students in the same manner and conferring the same grades of award, as if the Civil Service Commission were still waiting to hand out appointment letters.

In the years since, the population has more than quadrupled, the economy has become mostly informal, and problems with electricity, food supply, water, and security have piled up, yet universities kept training students for interviews that were no longer being held.

How University Certificates no longer guarantee a job

How University Certificate no longer guarantee a job

Addressing those parents who had sold land and borrowed money, he said they had honoured their part of the arrangement, but a certificate no longer promises a job. A degree used to vouch for three rare skills:

  • reading a large volume of material,
  • writing an organised account,
  • and following procedure.
None of these is rare any longer. Each graduate carries a device in their pocket that reads quicker than any lecturer and produces a report within a minute.

He spoke as Chairman of the committee overseeing the Centres of Excellence in AI, Robotics and Cyber Sciences. As he put it, AI begins by absorbing the routine work of the mind. The lowest rung of the career ladder is being cut away just as you stretch to grasp it.

Value now rests less on what you can copy out than on what you are able to judge. A machine can supply ten answers, but it cannot tell you which one succeeds in Kabba and fails in Kano, because it has never set foot in Kabba.

Drawing on the NBS Labour Force Survey for Q2 2024, he said unemployment stood at 4.3 per cent across the whole population and 4.8 per cent among those with post-secondary education, under a definition that counts anyone working a single hour a week as being in work. Of every 100 Nigerians in work, roughly 86 are self-employed or work for their families, and only 14 are paid staff.

About 3.5 million young people enter the labour market each year. The claim that graduates cannot be employed, he suggested, overlooks the fact that the economy has not produced graduate jobs as fast as universities have produced graduates.

As he describes it, an intelligence machine receives challenges from the world around it, applies the instruments of scholarly fields to them, and then hands what it finds to those with the power to act. He contended that Nigerian higher-education institutions do well at the central step, since the methods belong to them, yet falter at both the start and the finish.

Challenges arrive without any structured channel, and the conclusions drawn are largely aimed at other scholars. Our institutions are Mode 1 seats of learning placed in a nation brimming with Mode 2 difficulties.

He asked where the laboratory of a university would be, if the university is a machine. For Lokoja, the laboratory is the low-lying floodland at Ganaja and Adankolo, the trailer park, the market, the quarry site at Anikpa, the council offices where the budget is drawn up, and the health centre where the drugs never turned up. Society itself is the laboratory. A community that gives a scholar its time is a partner, and is entitled to see the results first.

The Shelf Problem

The Shelf Problem

Next, he raised an issue he labelled The Shelf Problem. In their final year, nearly every graduate produces a project that consumes months, is examined and scored, and then ends up gathering dust on a shelf. At best, two or three readers ever open it.

Take a thousand such projects, each costing three months of work, and the effort adds up to 250 years. Nationwide, the yearly total runs into the hundreds of thousands. In his view, this is the largest pool of researchers Nigeria has, left idle and busy with subjects picked simply because the supervisor had overseen them earlier.

Incentives explain it. Academics move up the ranks according to how many papers they get into print, and a piece on a general topic finds a journal more easily than an investigation into drainage problems in Lokoja does. Courses are accredited when they can show enough staff and a well-stocked library.

Nobody on an accreditation panel asks a department to point to even one difficulty in its surrounding community that has eased because the department is there. Meanwhile, students have discovered that software can do their coursework for them.

The answer is to give assignments that software cannot complete. It can pull together a review of the existing literature on urban floods across Nigeria. What it cannot do is go to Ganaja in September, record how high the water rose by marking the flood line on a wall, and ask the woman who lives in the house what she has lost.

Lokoja as a living laboratory for Universities

Kogi's own terrain supplied four examples. Begin with Lokoja: it stands at the confluence of two rivers, and the main north-south highway cuts through it too. Each day, lorries loaded with fuel, cement, grain, and livestock inch their way across the city. The river port at Jamata, which has been under development for upwards of ten years, is about 75 per cent complete, and a 64-tonne crane has already been contracted for it. Once it was running, barges could carry freight.

The number of lorries that go through daily, the goods they haul, the saving from shipping a tonne to Onitsha on the river rather than the road, and the months when the water runs deep enough for navigation are all questions that 50 students in their last year of study could settle in a single sitting.

Below the surface lies the second example. Kogi is home to coal at Ankpa, as well as limestone deposits at Obajana and iron ore found at Itakpe, and a large share of these resources is extracted by small-scale, informal miners who keep no records of what they take.

Geology departments could chart where the deposits lie, Chemistry could analyse the water in nearby streams, Law could look into who owns the land and what rights the host communities hold, and Sociology could work out the true identity of the people doing the digging.

Food is the proposal's third focus. Nigeria is estimated to have lost 30 to 40 million tonnes of produce once it had been harvested in 2025, a loss valued at 3.5 trillion to 5 trillion Naira. Part of this spoilage involves tomatoes, cassava, and yams grown in Kogi, since cold storage is absent in both Ejule and Anyigba. Students, he suggested, might devise a refrigerated storage unit powered by the sun, built from materials found locally, and calculate the cost of building it.

The fourth area is steel. Government officials say discussions are in progress on bringing Ajaokuta back to life, which would need 1.5 to 2 billion dollars. Itakpe's iron ore sits only an hour by road from the university campus. Nearby engineers and economists could begin at once on modelling whether small-scale plants that use electric arc furnaces and direct reduced iron might convert Itakpe concentrate into rebar.

The Confluence Problem Register proposal

He proposed what he called the Confluence Problem Register. Every year, the university would write to the Kogi State Government, the 21 local councils, NIWA, cement and mining companies, clinics and hospitals, traders' associations and the traditional rulers' councils, asking each to name the three problems it most wants to be solved. The answers would go into the register, and each department would draw a fixed share of its topics for students in their last undergraduate year and for postgraduates from it. At each Convocation, the university would report which problems had been taken on and what had been learnt. The plan is nearly free and requires no sign-off from Abuja, and would allow FUL to become the earliest university that can say what has changed in its host community because it exists.

The quadruple helix and civil society

He anchored his proposal in the quadruple helix. In the 1990s, Etzkowitz and Leydesorff set out a triple helix linking higher education, business, and the state; Carayannis and Campbell added a fourth strand in 2009, made up of civil society and ordinary citizens, whose outlook is moulded by the media and culture. Within Nigeria, 328 institutions give the university strand plenty of weight, the government strand is knotted, and the industry strand is slender. Civil society, however, is anything but slender: traders' groups, unions of drivers, hometown associations, chieftaincy councils, churches, mosques, local radio stations and networks of former students all endure. One study found that much research is completed but hardly any of it makes it to market, and that the civil society strand remains largely underdeveloped. The register, he said, would weave all four strands together.

His first of six recommendations, addressed to the Minister of Education, the NUC and CVCNU, concerns the 30 per cent. Under the CCMS, the Commission sets 70 per cent of the curriculum and hands the remaining 30 per cent to each Senate. ASUU described the arrangement as an emasculation of the Senate. In his view, it is the widest opening the regulator has left, yet most universities passed through it with more of the same courses. He wants universities to devote that 30 per cent to their own surroundings, which for Lokoja means the river, the road, minerals and flooding.

His second recommendation is for the finishing school to be built into the degree itself. He pointed out that banks and consultancies put their new graduates through structured training programmes because universities release unfinished products into the market. What he wants is for short professional certificates to earn credit within the 30 per cent, and for any industry qualification a student earns in the final year to appear on the transcript.

His third proposal is to replace two rival accreditation processes with a single one. COREN ruled in September 2023 that programmes at five universities were illegal, as they had not received its own accreditation. The student, he said, pays the price of a dispute over boundaries. He suggests combined panels making a single visit, using one instrument and issuing one verdict, all steered by one question: which problem in the surrounding area is lessened because this faculty is there?

Fourth, he urges institutions to get their own data affairs in order. In February, the Nigeria Data Protection Commission served compliance notices on 649 tertiary institutions over audit returns and the appointment of a Data Protection Officer. A university that asks its community to open up its records, he argued, must demonstrate that its own records are secure. He proposes that data protection become a duty of Council and be assessed during accreditation.

His fifth proposal is that the delivery of projects should be taught as a discipline in its own right. In his view, the habit of leaving a sound idea unfinished before it yields anything plagues the university and the government alike. The health sciences, he noted, built up implementation science to examine how research findings end up being taken on. He would create a postgraduate diploma and a master's degree, open to students from any field, where the dissertation requires the student to get one stalled project or policy moving again. The Jamata port, the Ejule refrigerated store and the Problem Register itself would all serve well as case studies.

The sixth item on his list is a system for following up on alumni once they have left campus. He said FUL exists to turn out graduates capable of securing employment and supporting themselves. Yet while the university announces how many students finish with first class honours, he observed, it says nothing about how many of those same people are employed a year afterwards. In Britain, he pointed out, institutions survey their graduates about 64 weeks after they leave and make the results public for all to see. His proposal, therefore, is a Graduate Destination Survey to be conducted between one year and a year and a half after every Convocation.

Credit and capital for graduates

According to him, two things lie beyond what a university can offer a graduate: start-up capital and a place to operate from. Financial inclusion has been judged by the number of accounts opened, and coverage stood at 64 per cent of people in 2023. All graduating students have an account, yet hardly any of them could secure enough credit to buy a machine. The Education Loan Fund, created under the 2024 Act, had by February 2025 supported more than 215,000 students. The Consumer Credit Corporation came into being in 2024, and its YouthCred loans, which run from 200,000 to 2 million and need no collateral, have gone to roughly 300,000 people, with 47 billion paid out. None of these institutions or schemes was around four years ago.

Yet the sequence is back to front. Credit is extended to get people into university, but next to none is offered for what comes afterwards. The graduate leaves owing the state while possessing nothing. The loans are small: dividing 47 billion by 300,000 borrowers gives about 157,000 apiece, which would buy a telephone but not a shredder. They are also costly, since two per cent monthly amounts to 24 per cent annually before compounding, against a CBN policy rate of 23 per cent. The money is fitted to trading, where one buys on Monday and sells by Friday, and not to equipment that takes two years to pay off. Assessment, moreover, rests on a payslip that a fresh graduate lacks.

This matters because the government wants young people to move into the sector. Under the Energy Transition Plan, up to 340,000 jobs could be created by 2030 and 840,000 by 2060. The Ministry of Youth started the Circular Economy Initiative, which spans all 774 LGAs, and launched it in August 2025, but it was given neither a budget nor an employment target. A circular economy turns used plastic into pellets, processes cassava peel into animal feed, presses rice husk into briquettes and runs cold storage on solar power; graduates in Kogi could set up and manage such businesses. Every one of these ventures, however, requires machinery and patient capital.

He proposes a Graduate Green Enterprise Window, hosted by either the Bank of Industry or the Development Bank of Nigeria, with money channelled through the partners the Consumer Credit Corporation already works with. Borrowers would be charged single-digit interest, would have between five and seven years to repay, and would enjoy a moratorium of at least twelve months, while equipment would be leased wherever feasible, so that the asset itself serves as security.

To make such projects bankable, he says a final-year project drawn from the Register, and validated by the department and by the body that submitted the problem, ought to stand in for the feasibility study on a first loan. In his words, in effect, the university vouches for the idea, a credit guarantee vouches for the loan, and no 23-year-old needs to go looking for collateral.

He also wants government to be the first customer: a share of its contracts for refuse collection, recycling, and maintenance of solar installations would be reserved for firms run by graduates who finished service within the previous five years. Education-loan repayments would be suspended while the business finds its footing, and an NYSC enterprise track would keep the allowance coming while the venture is built.

Housing as the next hurdle

Housing is the next hurdle: landlords demand a year's rent upfront, sometimes two, so the first big expense lands before the first pay cheque. Britain has spent over a decade handling first-time home buying as a policy question.

Since 2017, the Lifetime ISA has allowed people aged 18 to 39 to save £4,000 annually and receive a 25 per cent bonus; a mortgage guarantee, made a fixture in 2025, means a buyer putting down 5 per cent can borrow the remaining 95 per cent; part-buy schemes are open from a quarter share, and First Homes come with a discount of no less than 30 per cent.

The Budget of 28 October unveiled a £4.7 billion Your First Home scheme, requiring a 2.5 per cent down payment, under which the state advances 20 per cent as an interest-free loan for five years, with about 70,000 families expected to benefit.

His point is about principle, not about copying Britain. Since 1992 the National Housing Fund has deducted 2.5 per cent of workers' basic pay and offered loans at 6 per cent over three decades. Its terms look more generous on paper, yet with six million people paying in, the Federal Mortgage Bank recorded under 500 home loans.

The ministry now wants the ceiling lifted to 85 million and 5,000 home loans delivered by 2028. The newer Real Estate Investment Fund charges 9.75 per cent across 20 years and asks for a 10 per cent stake from the buyer; by June it had advanced 128 billion to 1,859 households, roughly 69 million each, with the typical beneficiary aged 42. It serves people who have already made it.

Every housing announcement this year carried provisions for the diaspora and for informal workers, but nothing for a young person buying a first home.

His suggestion is a First Home Savings Account inside the Housing Fund, open to those under 35. For each naira saved towards a first home, government would add a quarter, up to a cap, released only when the person buys or enters a rent-to-own deal.

Under Renewed Hope Housing, 100 units would be built in each of the 774 LGAs, with a fixed portion set aside for under-35s, whose monthly payments would count towards ownership and who would need no upfront sum other than the first quarter-year of payments.

He also proposes a starter equity loan in which the Fund holds a fifth of the property's value, so the young buyer needs only a small deposit. States, he says, should pass and enforce laws allowing rent to be paid monthly or quarterly, as Lagos began doing under its Tenancy Law 2011. The Housing Fund should also admit the self-employed and people who earn online.

Three routes open to this generation

He then outlined three routes available to this generation. Beyond Lokoja, the waterway never reaches the sea through a single mouth; it splits into many channels.

Stay means building a life at home. The first job will probably be beneath your qualification, with pay short of your needs. Few such jobs sit in offices with cooling systems; most are found in modest businesses, agriculture, the processing of food, building, haulage and distribution, classrooms, health centres and skilled crafts.

Many of these businesses have never employed a degree-holder, because no one with a degree ever showed them what such a person could do. Rewards come gradually in the beginning, but they come through familiar ground, relatives and contacts, and through so many problems that anyone who solves them soon builds a business or a name.

The price is heavy: poor roads, insecurity, and a state that often hinders before it helps. It is not the easy option, but it may reach the furthest.

Leaving is now the thing to do. Nigerians have been travelling abroad to find work since the 1920s, and long before the japa wave there was Andrew, who left in the 1980s. Lokoja's own story is one of outsiders who arrived to trade.

In the latest year, money sent home by the diaspora came to roughly 21.8 billion dollars, making it one of the country's largest earners of foreign exchange. Leaving, however, asks for payment up front: charges, evidence of savings and plane tickets. Several host countries have lately closed their borders.

On arrival, a qualification is frequently downgraded, and it can take years of work beneath your level of training. What you get in exchange is pay in a currency that holds its worth, plus institutions that actually function.

The price is distance from your parents, attending weddings and funerals through a phone screen, and the loneliness of being a stranger. He says that whoever goes should carry a skill, keep their eyes open and avoid burning bridges. In his view, the compatriots most worth having are those who left, learned how matters are handled overseas and kept a foothold back home.

Log In was not around when he left university. From Lokoja, a person can now serve a client based in Lagos, London, or Toronto. Earning that way takes a skill that a stranger is willing to pay for, plus evidence that you have it. Online, nobody enquires about your degree classification; they want to see your past work. You must supply your own power and data. Payment platforms also look warily at a Nigerian address.

There is no pension and no leave. Still, when the money comes, it is earnings in a foreign currency set against Nigerian living costs, and it can seed capital. Few people will stick to a single route for good. You will remain and log in, then leave and come back. The routes meet again out at sea.

See: In Machine Learning vs Artificial Intelligence, AI systems

He said the single possession you carry into every place is your name. Around us are faked credentials, voices cloned by software and messages composed by machines. Someone whose promise can be trusted is therefore scarce, and scarcity commands a premium.

Some people will mistrust you beforehand because of where you hail from. The only remedy is to do what you said you would, by the time you said you would. Every time someone does, the path widens a little for the next Nigerian.

The university says it values dedication, innovation, integrity, respect, and diligence. To a client thousands of miles away on another continent, integrity is the only assurance on offer. Diligence means carrying on learning once the last exam is behind you.

The university's responsibility stretches beyond this week. For the alumnus who remains at home, it must open doors to employers and connect him with the problems of the region. For the alumnus who departs, it must supply a transcript sent without delay.

A graduate who loses a place or a job because the university could not dispatch a transcript has been let down after the fees were collected. For the graduate who works online, it must provide a campus with reliable electricity and network, and an alumni community in which older members pass work down to younger ones.

Challenges to the university, government and industry

He drew his points together into a challenge. To the university: direct its projects towards the outside world, create a register, devote thirty per cent of its effort to its own surroundings, and change what counts towards promotion so that a lecturer whose work lessened the harm of the Ganaja flood is recognised as having achieved more.

Reward the student who solved a problem for a local government just as you reward the one whose paper appeared in a periodical that no one in Kogi will ever open, and trace what happened to its graduates. Speaking as National Chairman of ANUA, he said that when graduates are called on to contribute, they ask what they are contributing to, and the university should give them an answer. A university that tackles the problems of its host communities will not have to plead with its alumni.

To government: bring your problems to the university gate. You say universities are irrelevant, yet you have never sent one a single letter. You pay consultants flown in from Abuja and overseas to examine a river that a lecturer here has observed for fifteen years.

The Federal Government managed to find funds to lend for fees; it should work out how to finance a first enterprise and a first home with the same seriousness.

To industry: the expertise you need is next door, and it costs less than you imagine. Bring your problem to the university before you advertise for a consultant.

Turning to the press and the wider community of citizens' groups, he called them the fourth strand and the most powerful of all. Market associations, unions of townspeople, councils of traditional rulers and radio stations, he said, ought to bring their problems forward, and every November should publicly ask what has been done about them.

Addressing the graduates, he said they had been working in a laboratory for four years or longer, whether or not anybody had told them so. The real degree, he said, is the habit of asking questions, investigating, and separating what is established from what is merely claimed; the certificate is only a receipt. He urged them to take that habit into whatever channel they choose.

Faced with a problem, they should not say that somebody else ought to act, because they are now that somebody. The country had trained them at a cost higher than the fees their parents paid. Once they are established, he said, they should return something to where they began, and not only money, although the university would gladly accept it.

They should return problems, word of what skills employers wanted that they were never taught, and an attachment slot for one student. A river draws its strength from its source, he said, and the source is here.

Pointing to a place where two rivers converge and run alongside one another for some distance, each retaining its separate hue, the speaker told Federal University Lokoja's graduating class that the contest between the two eases off farther on.

From there, he said, one wider and more powerful river takes the merged water out to the sea. He described the graduates as that very water. Virgil is the source of the university's motto, 'this is the way to the stars'. The speaker said that the voyage towards those stars starts at this point and follows a river's course, and he called on the students to begin it and bring the entire country along.