Geeky Nigeria
Sports

Pochettino takes over at Man United after Carrick sacking

Paul Elegbeleye6 min read

Pochettino takes over at Man United after Carrick sacking
Audience, soccer and stadium. Photo: Pexels / Pixabay

Mauricio Pochettino takes charge at Manchester United after Michael Carrick's dismissal. Can the Argentine rebuild United and restore their winning identity?

Manchester United have turned to Mauricio Pochettino in another attempt to restore the club's identity, competitiveness, and place among English football's elite.

The Argentine's appointment marks the beginning of another rebuilding chapter at Old Trafford, following Michael Carrick's dismissal after a disastrous start to the 2026/27 Premier League season.

For a club that has spent more than a decade searching for stability since Sir Alex Ferguson's departure, the appointment represents another significant gamble.

Pochettino arrives with a reputation for developing young players, building energetic teams and establishing recognisable footballing identities. However, his managerial career also presents an important question: can a coach whose greatest achievements have largely come without major trophies deliver the sustained success Manchester United desperately need?

The challenge is enormous.

Why Manchester United Chose Pochettino

Pochettino's appointment is not entirely surprising.

His previous work in the Premier League, particularly at Southampton and Tottenham Hotspur, established him as a manager capable of building competitive teams without necessarily relying on the financial resources available to Europe's wealthiest clubs.

At Southampton, he developed an energetic and progressive team that attracted attention for its pressing intensity and attacking organisation.

His greatest achievement in England came at Tottenham, where he transformed the club into regular Champions League contenders and guided them to the 2019 Champions League final.

Although Tottenham failed to win the final against Liverpool, Pochettino's work demonstrated his ability to build a competitive team and develop players into important performers.

His experience at Paris Saint-Germain also brought a Ligue 1 title, although his time in France did not deliver the European success expected of him. His subsequent spell at Chelsea ended without a major trophy.

For Manchester United, however, the attraction appears to be his ability to create a footballing identity, improve players and build a competitive team.

These are qualities the club has struggled to sustain.

What Pochettino Brings Tactically

One of Pochettino's most recognisable characteristics is his preference for high-intensity football. His teams generally seek to press opponents, recover possession quickly and attack with speed.

At Manchester United, this approach could address some of the problems that have affected the team.

1. A More Aggressive Pressing System

United have struggled to maintain defensive organisation and apply consistent pressure on opponents.

Pochettino is likely to demand greater coordination between the attacking players and midfielders when pressing. Rather than allowing opponents to build attacks comfortably, United could become more aggressive in closing passing lanes and forcing mistakes.

However, successful pressing requires collective discipline. If the forwards press without support from the midfield, opponents can easily exploit the spaces left behind.

2. Better Midfield Organisation

Manchester United need a midfield capable of controlling matches, protecting the defence and supporting attacking transitions.

Pochettino will have to identify the right combination of players to provide balance. His preferred style requires midfielders who can cover ground, compete for possession and make intelligent decisions under pressure.

The challenge will be finding the right balance between defensive responsibility and creative freedom.

3. Developing Young Players

This is arguably one of Pochettino's strongest qualities.

His work with young players at Tottenham helped establish his reputation as a manager who could develop talent and turn promising footballers into important members of a competitive squad.

Manchester United have traditionally valued youth development, and Pochettino could provide an opportunity to strengthen that culture.

Players must be selected on merit, however, rather than reputation or transfer value.

The Immediate Challenge: Liverpool at Anfield

Pochettino could hardly have asked for a more demanding introduction. His first match in charge is scheduled to be against Liverpool at Anfield on November 22.

It is a fixture that carries enormous significance for both clubs and their supporters.

United are currently 18th in the Premier League, having recorded just one victory in their first ten league matches. They have also managed only three victories in 15 matches across all competitions.

The immediate priority must therefore be restoring confidence, improving defensive organisation and making the team more competitive.

A new manager often brings renewed enthusiasm, but the tactical transformation cannot happen overnight.

Pochettino will have limited time to work with his squad before facing one of United's biggest rivals.

The Liverpool match will offer an early indication of the direction he intends to take, although it should not be treated as the final judgement on his appointment.

See: Raphinha has been given two years deal by Barcelona

The Pochettino Risk: Can He Deliver Trophies?

For all his managerial qualities, Pochettino's trophy record remains a subject of debate. He built an excellent Tottenham side but did not win a major trophy during his time there.

At PSG, he won the French league title but failed to deliver the Champions League success the club expected.

His Chelsea spell also ended without a major trophy.

Manchester United are not appointing a manager simply to make the team play attractive football.

They need someone capable of restoring their competitiveness, challenging for major honours and eventually returning the club to the Premier League title conversation.

Pochettino must therefore demonstrate that he can translate his tactical philosophy into consistent results and silverware.

That is the standard against which his appointment will eventually be judged.

The Bigger Problem: Can Manchester United Support Him?

Perhaps the most important question surrounding this appointment has little to do with tactics.

It concerns the club's footballing structure.

Manchester United have appointed several managers since Ferguson retired, yet the club has repeatedly struggled to establish continuity.

Each new appointment has arrived with expectations of rebuilding, tactical improvement and a return to winning ways.

However, managerial changes alone have not resolved the underlying problems. Pochettino must be supported by a recruitment strategy that reflects his footballing philosophy.

The club's leadership must also provide clarity about its long-term objectives, transfer priorities and expectations.

A manager cannot build a sustainable project if recruitment decisions continually undermine the system he is trying to establish. This is where United must demonstrate that they have learned from previous mistakes.

The appointment should not become another isolated experiment. It must be part of a coordinated footballing project.

What Success Should Look Like

Pochettino's first responsibility is to move Manchester United away from the relegation zone and restore consistency. Beyond that, the club must begin to demonstrate measurable progress.

There should be improvements in defensive organisation, midfield control, pressing intensity and the development of younger players. United also need to establish a recognisable style of football that supporters can identify with.

Winning matches will be essential, but the long-term objective must be to build a team capable of competing consistently at the highest level.

The club cannot afford another rebuilding project that collapses after a difficult run of results.

Final Verdict: A New Opportunity, but an Old Responsibility

Mauricio Pochettino has the experience, tactical philosophy and Premier League knowledge to make his Manchester United appointment an interesting one.

His achievements at Tottenham demonstrate that he can build a competitive side and develop players. His experience at PSG and Chelsea has also exposed him to the pressures of managing elite football clubs. But Manchester United represent a different kind of challenge.

The expectations are enormous, the scrutiny is relentless and the club's recent history demonstrates how difficult it has become to restore sustained success at Old Trafford.

Pochettino must prove that he can do more than improve performances. He must build a team capable of winning important matches, competing for trophies and restoring belief among supporters.

The club's leadership must also prove that it can provide the stability and support required for such a project.

Manchester United have changed managers once again. The real test is whether they have finally changed the way they build a football club.

Pochettino has been handed the opportunity. Now comes the difficult part: turning that opportunity into a lasting revival.

See: Nigeria U-17 Global Cup champions land in Abuja to cheers